Stephen Witham (pictured) moved into Michael Flaherty's flat. The relationship quickly soured when Witham assaulted Flaherty's girlfriend, and stood over people for drugs and money. So Flaherty got some mates together, hit Witham about with baseball bats, hogtied him with ropes and cable ties, wrapped him in a doona, popped him in [...]

[Read more →]

Update, 2 June 2008: When I was writing the original post, I badly wanted to link to this classic motion to dismiss a criminal charge against a kid who called his principal 'a fucker, a fag, and a fucking fag', but it seems it was one thing I did not take with me when I [...]

[Read more →]

Ok, so it's the man better known as Justice Mark Weinberg of the Federal Court of Victoria, but damn is the man a judge of many courts at once. If I read Deakin University's staff profile properly, his Honour is concurrently a judge of:

the Federal Court;
the Supreme Court of Norfolk Island (he sentenced Janelle [...]

[Read more →]

My impression is that the legal ethics dialogue is highly developed in the United States. The extent to which people practice what is preached over there is something I have heard word about but can't guess at too accurately. Maybe its lawyers are more prone to extreme badness and so the discussion has [...]

[Read more →]

I had heard the rumour a fair while ago from the most impeccable sources in VCAT and the Supreme Court that the Supreme Court's Justice Bell was hot tip to take over from Judge Bowman as VCAT's head. Now it's confirmed. Frankly, though it would not be every lawyer's cup of tea, it's [...]

[Read more →]

Happy new year, readers. 2007 was a big one for me, and it seems that lots of interesting things happened. So I made a list.
The Bar: My senior mentor, Peter Riordan SC, was elected Chairman of the Bar Council. Peter Hayes QC died, and the Ethics Committee took Peter Faris to task for commenting to [...]

[Read more →]

Clayton Utz's Sally Shepherd has a good article about a recent decision of the Supreme Court of Victoria's Justice Bell on judges' duties to assist unrepresented litigants, and whether change is to be wrought on that front by the Charter of Human Rights and Responsibilities which will really start kicking next year. It is [...]

[Read more →]

It took an awfully long time — almost 15,000 words — for Justice Hansen to state the bleeding obvious in Attorney-General for the State of Victoria v Shaw [2007] VSC 1148, but in the circumstances, I well understand why his Honour desired to appeal-proof his judgment. Mr Shaw, who as a newly annointed vexatious litigant, [...]

[Read more →]

President Maxwell spoke at Jason Pizer's book launch the other night. There is no nonsense about him, and no hubris. I liked the way he sorted out Mr He's case, one which was sufficiently memorable for him to make reference to it in passing in his speech. The President is at pains to [...]

[Read more →]

A lawyer failed to show up for court one day. Then he appeared to explain: injured his ankle that morning. The judge said 'Take him away' and he went to jail, just like that. Now, for some reason, the judge is under investigation. They do everything bigger and better over there. Her Worship Pat O'Shane's [...]

[Read more →]